AapTaxLaw legal and tax information
Updated civil suit format

Suit for Compensation for Death or Injury Caused by Negligence

A practical civil plaint format for claiming damages where a wrongful act, neglect or default causes death or bodily injury. The sample below is drafted around a building-collapse negligence claim and should be adapted to the facts, parties, valuation, court-fee law and territorial jurisdiction of the case.

Applicable law for negligence compensation claims

A civil claim for damages is based on the alleged wrongful act or negligence and the resulting loss. In a case involving death, the Fatal Accidents Act, 1855 is important because section 1A provides for an action where death is caused by a wrongful act, neglect or default that would have entitled the injured person to recover damages had death not occurred.

The Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) governs the civil court process. In particular, section 9 concerns civil jurisdiction; sections 15, 19 and 20 are relevant to the proper court and place of suing; section 26 concerns institution of suits; and Order VII deals with the contents and presentation of a plaint.

For a death claim under the Fatal Accidents Act, the action is brought by the executor, administrator or representative of the deceased for the benefit of the wife, husband, parent and child, if any. Section 2 also permits a claim for pecuniary loss to the estate to be added, while section 3 requires the plaint to provide particulars of the persons for whose benefit the action is brought and the nature of the claim.

Important: A criminal case arising from the same incident does not by itself replace the civil claim for damages. Likewise, an insurer should be impleaded only where there is a legally relevant policy, contractual obligation or statutory basis for liability. The defendants must be selected according to the actual facts.

Jurisdiction, limitation, valuation and court fee

The suit must be filed before the civil court having both territorial jurisdiction and pecuniary jurisdiction. Depending on the facts, sections 15, 19 and 20 CPC may be relevant. The court designation should therefore not be hard-coded as "Senior Civil Judge" or "District Judge" unless that is correct under the applicable State law and the value of the claim.

For a suit by executors, administrators or representatives under the Fatal Accidents Act, 1855, Article 82 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963 prescribes two years from the date of death. Any question of exclusion, disability, acknowledgment, fraud, mistake or another special limitation rule must be examined on the actual facts before filing.

The plaint should state the amount claimed, the basis of valuation and the applicable court fee. Court-fee legislation and pecuniary limits vary by State/Union Territory, so the amount of court fee should be calculated under the law applicable to the court where the suit is instituted.

Documents commonly required

Depending on the case, useful documents may include the death certificate or medical records; FIR/complaint and police papers; post-mortem report where applicable; photographs, inspection reports or municipal/building records; proof of income and dependency; bills and receipts; correspondence or legal notice; identity and relationship documents; insurance policy documents where relevant; and any expert or technical material supporting negligence and causation.

Sample plaint: compensation for death caused by building-collapse negligence

Replace all blanks and optional clauses. Delete allegations that do not apply. The sample is illustrative and must be adapted to local pleading, court-fee and filing requirements.

IN THE COURT OF THE __________ AT __________

CIVIL SUIT NO. ______ OF 20__

IN THE MATTER OF:

__________,
aged about ___ years,
resident of ______________________________,
legal representative/representative of Late __________

...PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

1. __________
Owner/occupier of premises at ______________________________

...DEFENDANT NO. 1

2. __________
Builder/contractor/person responsible for construction at ______________________________

...DEFENDANT NO. 2

3. __________
[Insurer/other legally liable party, only if applicable]
Address: ______________________________

...DEFENDANT NO. 3

SUIT FOR RECOVERY OF DAMAGES/COMPENSATION FOR DEATH CAUSED BY WRONGFUL ACT, NEGLECT OR DEFAULT

MOST RESPECTFULLY SHOWETH:

  1. That the Plaintiff is the __________ of Late __________ ("the deceased") and is competent to institute the present suit as the executor/administrator/representative of the deceased. The suit is brought for the benefit of the persons entitled under section 1A of the Fatal Accidents Act, 1855, particulars of whom are stated below: ______________________________.
  2. That Defendant No. 1 is the owner/occupier/person in control of the building/premises situated at ______________________________. Defendant No. 2 was the builder/contractor/person carrying out or supervising the construction. [Set out the exact legal role of each defendant.]
  3. That on __________ at about __________, the deceased was lawfully present/passing near ______________________________ when the building/structure/construction portion suddenly collapsed and the deceased was struck/buried beneath debris.
  4. That the deceased suffered serious injuries and was taken to __________________ Hospital, where he/she was declared dead / subsequently died on __________. The death certificate, medical records and/or post-mortem report are relied upon.
  5. That the Defendants owed a duty to persons lawfully using or passing through the area to take reasonable precautions against foreseeable risk arising from the construction/building activity.
  6. That the Defendants failed to provide adequate barricading, warning signs, protective arrangements and/or other reasonable safety measures and permitted the dangerous area to remain accessible. [Retain only facts supported by evidence.]
  7. That the construction/structure was carried out, maintained or supervised negligently and without reasonable care, including ______________________________. [State specific acts or omissions and avoid general allegations where particulars are available.]
  8. That the wrongful act, neglect and/or default of the Defendants was the direct and proximate cause of the accident and the resulting death of the deceased.
  9. That the incident was reported to Police Station __________ and FIR/DD/GD/complaint No. __________ dated __________ was registered/recorded. [If applicable.] Any criminal investigation or prosecution is separate from the present civil claim.
  10. That at the time of death the deceased was aged about ___ years, was engaged as __________ and had an income of approximately Rs. __________ per month/annum. Documents supporting income are filed with the plaint.
  11. That the deceased was contributing approximately Rs. __________ per month toward the maintenance and support of the family. The persons for whose benefit this suit is brought suffered pecuniary loss and loss of support as a result of the death.
  12. That the Plaintiff also claims, where legally recoverable and supported by evidence, funeral expenses, medical expenses incurred before death, loss to the estate and other pecuniary losses arising from the wrongful act, neglect or default.
  13. That the Plaintiff demanded compensation from the Defendants by communication/legal notice dated __________, but the Defendants failed/refused to compensate the Plaintiff. [Delete if no demand was made or if not legally material.]
  14. That the cause of action first arose on __________ when the accident occurred and, in relation to the fatal claim, on __________ when the deceased died, and continues to subsist to the extent permissible in law.
  15. That this Hon'ble Court has territorial jurisdiction because ______________________________ [state facts showing where the wrong occurred, where the defendant resides/carries on business, or other applicable CPC basis].
  16. That this Hon'ble Court has pecuniary jurisdiction because the suit is valued at Rs. __________, being within the pecuniary limits applicable to this Court.
  17. That for purposes of jurisdiction and court fee, the suit is valued at Rs. __________ and the prescribed court fee of Rs. __________ is paid/affixed in accordance with the law applicable in __________ [State/UT].
  18. That the suit is within limitation under the applicable provisions of the Limitation Act, 1963. [If any exclusion or saving provision is relied upon, plead the necessary facts specifically.]

PRAYER

In the above facts and circumstances, it is respectfully prayed that this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to:

  1. pass a decree for Rs. __________ as damages/compensation in favour of the Plaintiff and against such of the Defendants as are found liable;
  2. award pre-suit, pendente lite and future interest at such rate and for such period as this Hon'ble Court considers lawful and appropriate, including under section 34 CPC where applicable;
  3. award costs of the suit; and
  4. grant any other or further relief that this Hon'ble Court deems fit in the interests of justice.

Place: __________
Date: __________

PLAINTIFF

THROUGH COUNSEL
__________________, Advocate

VERIFICATION

I, __________, the above-named Plaintiff, verify that the contents of paragraphs ___ to ___ are true and correct to my personal knowledge, paragraphs ___ to ___ are based on records/information believed to be true, and the legal submissions are based on advice received and believed to be correct. No material fact has knowingly been concealed.

Verified at __________ on this ___ day of __________, 20__.

PLAINTIFF

Frequently asked questions

Can a legal representative file a claim for death caused by negligence?

Yes. Section 1A of the Fatal Accidents Act, 1855 contemplates a suit in the name of the executor, administrator or representative of the deceased for the benefit of the wife, husband, parent and child, if any. The plaint should identify the persons for whose benefit the action is brought.

Is the limitation period always three years?

No. A fatal-accident suit under the Fatal Accidents Act is specifically covered by Article 82 of the Limitation Act, 1963, which prescribes two years from the date of death. Other personal-injury or tort claims may fall under different limitation provisions depending on their legal basis and facts.

Can the insurer automatically be made liable?

No. An insurer should not be added merely because an accident occurred. The pleading should identify the insurance policy and the contractual or statutory basis, if any, on which liability is asserted against that insurer.

Which court should be named in the heading?

The proper court depends on territorial jurisdiction, pecuniary jurisdiction and the local civil-court structure. The heading should therefore be completed only after checking the law and notifications applicable in the relevant State or Union Territory.