Home > Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 > Section 52

Section 52 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 - Chapter II Not to Apply

Section 52 is the closing provision of Part II, Chapter I of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. It separates the statutory regime for New York Convention awards in Chapter I from the Geneva Convention award regime in Chapter II by providing that Chapter II does not apply to foreign awards governed by Chapter I.

Text of Section 52 - Chapter II not to apply

Section 52. Chapter II not to apply.

Chapter II of this Part shall not apply in relation to foreign awards to which this Chapter applies.

Meaning and scope of Section 52

Section 52 prevents overlap between the two foreign-award Chapters contained in Part II. If a foreign award is governed by Chapter I, the provisions of Chapter II do not apply to that award.

The provision therefore operates as a statutory separation rule. Chapter I contains the regime applicable to New York Convention awards, while Chapter II contains the separate regime for Geneva Convention awards. Section 52 makes clear that an award falling within Chapter I is not to be processed under Chapter II.

Key point: Section 52 does not create a separate enforcement remedy. It identifies which Chapter of Part II applies by excluding Chapter II where Chapter I already governs the foreign award.

What is Chapter I of Part II?

Part II, Chapter I is titled New York Convention Awards. It contains Sections 44 to 52 and provides the statutory framework for recognition and enforcement in India of foreign awards falling within the New York Convention regime.

  • Section 44 defines a "foreign award" for Chapter I.
  • Section 45 deals with reference of parties to arbitration.
  • Section 46 explains when a foreign award is binding.
  • Section 47 specifies evidence for enforcement.
  • Section 48 sets out the conditions and limited grounds for refusing enforcement.
  • Section 49 deals with enforcement of an enforceable foreign award.
  • Section 50 specifies appealable orders.
  • Section 51 is the saving provision.
  • Section 52 excludes Chapter II where Chapter I applies.

What is Chapter II of Part II?

Part II, Chapter II is titled Geneva Convention Awards. It begins with Section 53 and continues through Section 60.

Section 53 contains the Chapter II definition of "foreign award" and refers to awards made after 28 July 1924 in pursuance of an arbitration agreement to which the Protocol set out in the Second Schedule applies, subject to the other statutory requirements stated in that section.

Difference between Chapter I and Chapter II

Part II, Chapter I Part II, Chapter II
New York Convention Awards Geneva Convention Awards
Sections 44 to 52 Sections 53 to 60
Section 44 provides the relevant definition of foreign award. Section 53 provides the relevant definition of foreign award.
Sections 47 to 49 govern evidence, refusal conditions, and enforcement. Sections 56 to 58 contain corresponding provisions for Chapter II awards.
Section 52 excludes Chapter II where Chapter I applies. Chapter II therefore does not govern an award already covered by Chapter I.

Why Section 52 matters

Section 52 helps determine the correct statutory route for a foreign award. Before applying the enforcement provisions of Part II, it is necessary to identify whether the award falls within the Chapter I New York Convention framework or the Chapter II Geneva Convention framework. Once Chapter I applies, Section 52 excludes Chapter II in relation to that award.

The precise classification of a foreign award depends on the statutory definitions, the arbitration agreement, the place and date of the award, applicable treaty requirements, relevant Central Government notifications, and the facts of the particular case.

Section 52 should be read with Section 44, Section 51, and Section 53. Section 44 defines foreign awards for Chapter I, Section 51 preserves certain otherwise existing rights, and Section 53 begins the separate definition and framework for Geneva Convention awards under Chapter II.

Legal note: This article provides the statutory text and a general explanation for research and information. For a particular enforcement proceeding, verify the current official Act, applicable treaty and notification requirements, jurisdiction, limitation, procedural rules, and binding judicial decisions.