Home > Court Fees Act 1870 > Section 15

Section 15 of the Court Fees Act 1870 - Refund When Court Reverses or Modifies Its Decision for Mistake

Section 15 of the Court-Fees Act, 1870 provides a specific refund mechanism where a review of judgment is admitted and, on rehearing, the court reverses or modifies its earlier decision because of a mistake of law or fact.

In brief: the provision applies to an admitted review that succeeds because the earlier decision contained a mistake of law or fact. It does not grant the Section 15 refund where the change in the decision is caused, wholly or partly, by fresh evidence that could have been produced at the original hearing.

Text and meaning of Section 15

Refund where Court reverses or modifies its former decision on ground of mistake. Where an application for a review of judgment is admitted, and where, on the rehearing, the Court reverses or modifies its former decision on the ground of mistake in law or fact, the applicant shall be entitled to a certificate from the Court authorising him to receive back from the Collector so much of the fee paid on the application as exceeds the fee payable on any other application to such Court under the Second Schedule to the Act, No. 1, clause (b) or clause (d).

The section further excludes the refund where the reversal or modification is due, wholly or in part, to fresh evidence which might have been produced at the original hearing.

Conditions for refund under Section 15

For the statutory refund mechanism to operate, the language of Section 15 requires the following elements:

What refund is contemplated?

Section 15 does not state that every rupee of court fee paid on the review application is refundable. It provides for a court certificate authorising refund of the amount by which the fee paid on the review application exceeds the fee payable on the other application specified by the provision under the Second Schedule.

Meaning of review of judgment

A review is a statutory procedure by which the same court may reconsider its judgment or order within the limits prescribed by the applicable procedural law. For civil proceedings, the Court-Fees Act itself refers to Section 114 and Order XLVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 in connection with applications for review of judgment.

Fresh evidence exception

The second paragraph of Section 15 is important. If the earlier decision is reversed or modified wholly or partly because of fresh evidence that could have been produced at the original hearing, the applicant is not entitled to the refund certificate under this section. The statutory distinction is therefore between correction of an earlier mistake of law or fact and a changed result produced by previously available evidence introduced later.

State amendments and local court-fee laws

Court-fee law is subject to State amendments and, in some States, separate State legislation. The applicable State law and current court-fee rules should therefore be checked before relying on the central text. For example, the official India Code text records a Tripura amendment to Section 15 concerning refund through the Collector or electronic transfer in the prescribed manner.

Official legal source

For the current central text, amendments reproduced with the Act, schedules and statutory notes, see the Court-Fees Act, 1870 on India Code.

Historical amendment note

The word "application" in Section 15 was substituted by Act 20 of 1870, Section 1, for the earlier words "plaint or memorandum of appeal".

Legal note: This page explains the central statutory provision for general legal information. Court-fee liability and refund procedure can vary because of State amendments, State enactments, rules and local practice.